| 
R (Clift) v Home Secretary; R (Hindawi and Headley) v Home Secretary | 
|   | 
  | 
| Issue:  | 
Whether the Home Secretary’s power to decide the release of those serving 15 years or more breached Arts 5 and 14 ECHR; whether it was lawful to discriminate between prisoners who subject to a deportation order with those who were not in respect of early release on parole. | 
|   | 
  | 
| Court:  | 
House of Lords | 
|   | 
  | 
| Reference:    | 
 | 
|   | 
  | 
| Neutral Citation:    | 
[2006] UKHL 54 | 
|   | 
  | 
| Judge(s):  | 
Lord Bingham, Lord Hope, Baroness Hale, Lord Carswell, Lord Brown | 
|   | 
  | 
| Date:  | 
13 December 2006 |